,

Error Code: 45728 – Authentication Error: Managed Identity Issue

Posted by

Background


Error code 45728 occurs when an Azure SQL Database is unable to authenticate with an external service, such as Azure Key Vault or Azure Storage, using a Managed Identity. Managed identities in Azure are used to provide secure, passwordless authentication to Azure services without requiring developers to manage credentials. This error typically occurs when the managed identity is not correctly configured, does not have the necessary permissions, or is not enabled on the Azure SQL Database or the external service.

Summary Table

AspectDetails
Error Code45728
Error MessageThe operation could not be completed because the database’s managed identity lacks required permissions.
BackgroundThe database’s managed identity lacks permissions or is not correctly configured to access external resources.
Common Causes1. Managed identity not enabled
2. Insufficient permissions
3. Firewall restrictions
Workarounds1. Use a service principal
2. Check access logs for more information
Solutions1. Enable managed identity
2. Grant permissions on the target resource
3. Check firewall and network settings
Example Query to Grant AccessSet-AzKeyVaultAccessPolicy -VaultName 'your-keyvault' -ObjectId 'your-managed-identity-id' -PermissionsToSecrets get,list

Error Explanation

The error message typically reads:

Error 45728: The operation could not be completed because the database's managed identity does not have the required permissions to access the resource.

This error indicates that Azure SQL Database is attempting to use its managed identity to access a resource (like Azure Key Vault or Azure Blob Storage), but it either:

  • Lacks the necessary permissions on the target resource.
  • The managed identity was not enabled or configured correctly.
  • The external service (e.g., Azure Key Vault) is blocking access.

Common Causes:

  1. Insufficient Permissions: The managed identity does not have the necessary permissions to access the target resource.
  2. Managed Identity Not Enabled: The managed identity is not enabled for the Azure SQL Database.
  3. Incorrect Resource Configuration: The target resource (e.g., Key Vault) is not configured to allow access from the Azure SQL Database.
  4. Network or Firewall Issues: The target resource is protected by firewalls or network settings that block access from Azure SQL Database.
  5. Token Expiration: The authentication token associated with the managed identity may have expired.

Steps to Troubleshoot and Resolve Error Code 45728

1. Ensure Managed Identity is Enabled on Azure SQL Database

First, ensure that the managed identity feature is enabled for your Azure SQL Database. There are two types of managed identities in Azure:

  • System-assigned managed identity: Tied to the lifecycle of the Azure SQL Database and automatically managed by Azure.
  • User-assigned managed identity: Can be shared across multiple resources and assigned manually.

Steps to Check Managed Identity:

  1. Go to the Azure Portal.
  2. Navigate to your SQL Database.
  3. Under Settings, click on Identity.
  4. Ensure that System-assigned managed identity is enabled.

If the managed identity is not enabled, you must turn it on before proceeding.

Example of Enabling Managed Identity:

  • System-assigned Managed Identity:
    • Toggle the system-assigned identity to On.
    • Save the changes to enable the managed identity for the SQL Database.

2. Grant Permissions to the Target Resource

After enabling the managed identity, you need to assign the proper permissions on the external resource, such as Azure Key Vault or Azure Blob Storage, that the SQL Database is trying to access.

For example, if the Azure SQL Database is trying to access secrets in Azure Key Vault, you need to grant the managed identity the necessary Key Vault Access Policy.

Steps to Grant Key Vault Access:

  1. Go to the Azure Portal.
  2. Navigate to your Key Vault.
  3. Under Settings, click Access policies.
  4. Click Add Access Policy.
  5. Select the appropriate permissions (e.g., Get, List) under the Secret Permissions section.
  6. Under Principal, click Select Principal and find the system-assigned or user-assigned managed identity of your Azure SQL Database.
  7. Save the changes.

Example Command to Grant Access via PowerShell:

$kvName = "your-keyvault-name"
$identityObjectId = "managed-identity-object-id"

Set-AzKeyVaultAccessPolicy -VaultName $kvName -ObjectId $identityObjectId -PermissionsToSecrets get,list

3. Check the Target Resource’s Network and Firewall Configuration

Azure resources like Key Vault or Storage Accounts are often protected by network and firewall rules that restrict access. You need to ensure that the Azure SQL Database can connect to these resources.

Steps to Allow Access in Key Vault:

  1. Go to Azure Portal.
  2. Navigate to your Key Vault.
  3. Under Settings, select Networking.
  4. Ensure that the Firewall and Virtual Networks settings allow access from the Azure SQL Database. If necessary, allow access to trusted Microsoft services.

If the database resides in a virtual network (VNet), ensure that the Key Vault or other external resources also have the proper access rules to allow communication between the services.

4. Ensure Correct Configuration for User-Assigned Managed Identity

If you are using a User-assigned Managed Identity, ensure that the identity is properly assigned to the SQL Database and that it has the required access permissions.

Steps to Assign User-assigned Managed Identity:

  1. Go to Azure Portal.
  2. Navigate to your SQL Database.
  3. Under Identity, click on User-assigned.
  4. Click Add, select the user-assigned identity, and assign it to the database.

Ensure that the identity has the necessary permissions on the target resource (Key Vault, Storage, etc.).

5. Check the Expiration of the Token or Credentials

The managed identity uses tokens to authenticate against resources. These tokens have an expiration time, after which they need to be refreshed. Ensure that the token used by the managed identity has not expired, especially if the identity was recently created or the request is long-running.

You can refresh the managed identity token by restarting the Azure SQL Database or the application that is using it.

Steps to Refresh Managed Identity Token:

  1. Go to Azure Portal.
  2. Navigate to your SQL Database.
  3. Under Settings, click Restart.

6. Retry the Operation After Correcting Permissions

Once you have confirmed that the managed identity is enabled, permissions are correctly assigned, and networking/firewall settings are configured, retry the operation.

If the issue was related to insufficient permissions or misconfiguration, retrying the query or operation should now succeed.

Workarounds

  • Use a Service Principal: Instead of using a managed identity, you can authenticate to Azure resources using a service principal. This requires you to manage credentials and secrets but offers more granular control over permissions.
  • Check Access Logs: Azure Key Vault and other services have access logs that you can use to track authentication failures and ensure the identity has the correct permissions.

Solutions

  1. Enable Managed Identity: Ensure that the managed identity is enabled on the Azure SQL Database.
  2. Grant Permissions to the Resource: Assign the required permissions to the managed identity on the external resource (e.g., Azure Key Vault, Blob Storage).
  3. Configure Networking and Firewalls: Ensure that firewall and network rules allow Azure SQL Database to access external resources.
  4. Use Correct Managed Identity: Make sure you are using the correct system-assigned or user-assigned managed identity with the appropriate access levels.
  5. Refresh Tokens: Refresh the authentication tokens by restarting the database if necessary.

Example Scenario

Suppose you’re using Azure SQL Database to access secrets stored in Azure Key Vault for encryption keys, and you receive the following error:

Error 45728: The operation could not be completed because the database's managed identity does not have the required permissions to access the resource.

Step 1: You go to the Azure Portal and check the Identity settings for your Azure SQL Database. You confirm that the system-assigned managed identity is enabled.

Step 2: You then navigate to the Key Vault and realize that the SQL Database’s managed identity is not listed in the Access Policies.

Step 3: You add the SQL Database’s managed identity to the Key Vault’s access policy and grant it Get and List permissions for secrets.

Step 4: You check the Key Vault firewall settings and confirm that trusted Microsoft services are allowed to access the Key Vault.

Step 5: After updating the access policy, you retry the operation in Azure SQL Database, and it completes successfully.

guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x